What Are Home Equity Loans and Refinancing?

A home equity loan allows you to borrow against the equity you've built in your property while keeping your original mortgage intact. You receive a lump sum with a fixed interest rate and make regular payments over a set term, typically 5-30 years. This creates a second mortgage on your property, secured by your home.

In contrast, mortgage refinancing replaces your existing home loan with an entirely new mortgage, often with different terms and rates. When you refinance, you can potentially borrow more than you currently owe (cash-out refinance) or simply secure better terms on your existing balance (rate-and-term refinance). Both options use your home as collateral, making it crucial to understand the differences before deciding.

How Each Option Works

With a home equity loan, you maintain your primary mortgage while adding a second loan against your property's equity. The amount you can borrow typically ranges from 80-85% of your home's value minus your remaining mortgage balance. You'll receive the entire loan amount upfront and begin making fixed monthly payments immediately.

When refinancing, you're essentially starting over with a new loan. The process involves a complete application, credit check, home appraisal, and closing costs—similar to your original mortgage. With cash-out refinancing, you borrow more than you currently owe and pocket the difference. For example, if your home is worth $400,000 and you owe $200,000, you might refinance for $250,000 and receive $50,000 in cash while starting fresh with a new loan term.

Provider Comparison: Home Equity Loan vs Refinance Options

Several financial institutions offer both home equity loans and refinancing options with varying terms and benefits:

  • Rocket Mortgage: Offers streamlined refinancing with digital application processes and competitive rates. Rocket Mortgage specializes in quick closings but has more limited home equity loan options.
  • Bank of America: Provides both home equity loans and refinancing with relationship discounts for existing customers. Bank of America offers fixed-rate home equity loans with no application fees.
  • Wells Fargo: Features both options with flexible terms and potential interest rate discounts. Wells Fargo offers relationship discounts that can lower your overall costs.
  • LendingTree: This marketplace allows you to compare multiple lenders for both home equity loans and refinancing options. LendingTree can help you find competitive rates across numerous providers.

Benefits and Drawbacks of Each Option

Home Equity Loan Benefits:

  • Maintains your original mortgage rate if it's already low
  • Fixed interest rates provide payment predictability
  • Minimal closing costs compared to full refinancing
  • Faster approval and funding process
  • Tax-deductible interest when used for home improvements

Home Equity Loan Drawbacks:

  • Higher interest rates than primary mortgages
  • Managing two separate mortgage payments
  • Potential for foreclosure if payments aren't maintained
  • May have shorter repayment terms

Refinance Benefits:

  • Potentially lower interest rates across your entire mortgage balance
  • Single monthly payment instead of multiple loans
  • Option to adjust loan term (shorter or longer)
  • Ability to remove mortgage insurance if you've gained sufficient equity

Refinance Drawbacks:

  • Higher closing costs (typically 2-5% of loan amount)
  • Resets your loan term, potentially increasing total interest paid
  • More extensive application and approval process
  • May lose a favorable interest rate on your current mortgage

When to Choose Each Option

Consider a home equity loan when:

  • Your current mortgage has a low interest rate you want to preserve
  • You need a specific amount for a defined purpose (home renovation, education)
  • You prefer fixed payments and terms
  • You want to minimize closing costs
  • You need funds relatively quickly

Consider refinancing when:

  • Current market rates are significantly lower than your existing mortgage rate
  • You want to consolidate multiple loans into one payment
  • You plan to stay in your home long enough to recoup closing costs
  • You want to change your loan term (shorter for faster payoff, longer for lower payments)
  • You need to remove a co-borrower from the original mortgage

Online marketplaces like Credible and comparison tools from NerdWallet can help you evaluate current rates and terms from multiple lenders to find the option that best suits your financial situation.

Conclusion

The choice between a home equity loan and refinancing ultimately depends on your specific financial situation, goals, and current mortgage terms. Home equity loans work best when you have a great rate on your existing mortgage and need funds for a specific purpose. Refinancing makes more sense when interest rates have dropped significantly or you want to simplify multiple loans into one payment. Before making any decision, calculate the total costs of each option, including interest over the full term and any fees. Consider consulting with financial advisors from institutions like Chase or Discover, who offer both products and can provide personalized guidance. Remember that both options use your home as collateral, so maintaining payments is crucial to protecting your property investment.

Citations

This content was written by AI and reviewed by a human for quality and compliance.