What Exactly Is a Common Law Claim?

A common law claim derives from the body of law developed through judicial decisions in court cases rather than through legislative statutes. This legal framework originated in England and spread throughout many English-speaking countries, becoming the foundation for much of their legal systems.

Common law operates on the principle of stare decisis, which means 'to stand by decisions.' Under this doctrine, judges are bound by the precedents established in previous similar cases. When filing a common law claim, you're essentially asking the court to apply these established precedents to your specific situation. These claims typically involve areas like contracts, torts (civil wrongs), and property disputes where court decisions have shaped the legal landscape over centuries.

How Common Law Claims Work

When you initiate a common law claim, you're entering a legal process that follows specific procedural rules. First, you must determine if your issue falls under common law jurisdiction rather than statutory law. Common law claims typically involve civil matters such as breach of contract, negligence, or property disputes.

The process begins with filing a complaint or petition with the appropriate court, outlining your claim and the legal basis for it. You'll need to demonstrate that your situation aligns with established precedents. The court then evaluates whether previous judicial decisions support your position. Evidence gathering becomes crucial at this stage, as you must present facts that align with successful previous cases.

Unlike statutory claims that rely on specific written laws, common law claims require showing how your case fits within the pattern of previous judicial decisions. This makes understanding case history and legal precedent particularly important when pursuing these types of claims.

Common Law Claim Provider Comparison

When seeking assistance with common law claims, several legal service providers offer specialized expertise. Here's how they compare:

ProviderSpecializationFee StructureClient Support
LegalZoomDIY legal documentsFlat-rate packagesEmail and phone
Rocket LawyerOnline legal servicesSubscription modelLive chat and phone
FindLawAttorney directoryVaries by attorneyDirectory services
NoloLegal informationBook and form salesSelf-help resources

When selecting a provider, consider their expertise in your specific type of common law claim. Avvo offers attorney ratings and reviews that can help assess an attorney's experience with common law matters. Meanwhile, Justia provides extensive legal resources and directories to help you understand the common law principles relevant to your case.

Benefits and Drawbacks of Common Law Claims

Common law claims offer several distinct advantages. Flexibility stands as perhaps the most significant benefit—common law can adapt to new situations even when legislation hasn't caught up. Since common law evolves through judicial decisions, it can address novel circumstances by applying established principles to new scenarios.

Another advantage is the predictability that comes from following precedents. By examining past cases, your legal representative can often forecast potential outcomes with reasonable accuracy. This predictability helps with decision-making about whether to pursue a claim.

However, common law claims also present challenges. They typically require more extensive legal research than statutory claims since you must identify and analyze relevant precedents. This can make them more time-consuming and costly to pursue. Additionally, common law varies by jurisdiction, creating inconsistencies across different regions.

The burden of proof in common law claims often falls heavily on the claimant, requiring substantial evidence to demonstrate how your case aligns with established precedents. The American Bar Association provides resources to help understand these evidentiary requirements.

Cost Considerations for Common Law Claims

The financial aspects of pursuing a common law claim deserve careful consideration. Legal representation typically constitutes the largest expense, with attorney fees varying based on experience, location, and case complexity. Many lawyers charge hourly rates for common law cases rather than contingency fees, as outcomes can be less predictable than in some statutory matters.

Court filing fees represent another necessary expense, typically ranging from $100 to $500 depending on the jurisdiction and claim type. If your case proceeds to trial, additional costs may include expert witness fees, which can be substantial depending on the expertise required.

Some legal service platforms like Priori Legal offer transparent pricing models for common law representation. Alternatively, LawHelp.org provides information about accessing reduced-cost legal services for those who qualify.

Consider also the opportunity costs—the time investment required to pursue your claim, potential delays in resolution, and the emotional toll of legal proceedings. Weighing these factors against the potential recovery value helps determine if pursuing a common law claim makes financial sense in your situation.

Conclusion

Common law claims represent a fundamental aspect of our legal system, providing remedies based on judicial precedent rather than codified statutes. While navigating this area requires understanding legal history and precedent, the system offers flexibility that statutory law sometimes lacks. Before pursuing a common law claim, consult with qualified legal professionals to evaluate your specific situation, understand potential outcomes, and develop a strategic approach. With proper preparation and guidance, you can effectively utilize the common law system to address your legal concerns.

Citations

This content was written by AI and reviewed by a human for quality and compliance.