What Makes the Forester Premium Stand Out

The Subaru Forester Premium trim sits in the middle of the Forester lineup, offering an excellent balance of features and value. When shopping for a used model, you'll find these vehicles typically include upgraded cloth upholstery, a panoramic moonroof, X-Mode for enhanced off-road capability, and a power-adjustable driver's seat that new base models don't offer.

Most used Premium models from recent years come equipped with Subaru's EyeSight driver assistance technology, which includes adaptive cruise control, pre-collision braking, and lane departure warning. The Premium trim also typically features a larger infotainment screen with smartphone integration, making it a significant step up from the base model without the higher price tag of the Limited or Touring trims.

Fuel economy remains consistent across model years, with most used Forester Premium models achieving approximately 26-33 MPG depending on driving conditions. This efficiency, combined with Subaru's symmetrical all-wheel drive system, makes the Forester Premium a practical choice for families and adventure seekers alike.

Key Model Years and Changes to Consider

When shopping for a used Subaru Forester Premium, understanding the differences between generations and model years can help you make a more informed decision. The fourth generation (2014-2018) Forester Premium models offer excellent value, featuring the essential Premium trim amenities while typically being more affordable than fifth-generation models.

The fifth generation debuted in 2019, bringing significant improvements in interior quality, technology, and safety features. These newer used models typically include an updated EyeSight system with more capabilities, enhanced sound insulation for a quieter ride, and slightly more interior space than previous generations.

Notable updates occurred in 2022 when Subaru refreshed the Forester with redesigned front fascia, headlights, and added Wilderness trim (though this is separate from the Premium). If purchasing a used 2017-2019 model, it's worth checking if the vehicle received the updates for the CVT transmission recall that affected some vehicles from this period.

Regardless of model year, all Forester Premium models maintain the 8.7 inches of ground clearance and symmetrical all-wheel drive that make these vehicles capable in diverse weather and road conditions. Most used models come with the 2.5-liter four-cylinder Boxer engine, providing consistent performance across years.

Used Forester Premium Marketplace Comparison

When looking for a used Subaru Forester Premium, several marketplaces offer different advantages for potential buyers. CarMax provides a no-haggle pricing model and typically offers a 30-day return policy on their used Foresters, giving buyers peace of mind with their purchase. Their inventory often includes certified pre-owned options with extended warranties.

For those seeking direct pricing comparisons, CarGurus provides market analysis tools that show whether a used Forester Premium is priced above or below market value. Their platform includes dealer and private party listings, offering a comprehensive view of available vehicles.

Subaru enthusiasts might prefer shopping through Subaru's certified pre-owned program, which provides factory-backed warranties on qualifying used Foresters. These vehicles undergo a comprehensive 152-point inspection and typically include roadside assistance.

The following table highlights key differences between major used car marketplaces for Forester Premium models:

Marketplace Typical Warranty Inspection Process Price Negotiation
CarMax 90-day/4,000-mile limited warranty 125+ point inspection No-haggle pricing
CarGurus Varies by seller Varies by seller Negotiable (market analysis provided)
Subaru CPO 7-year/100,000-mile powertrain 152-point inspection Some negotiation possible
AutoTrader Varies by seller Varies by seller Fully negotiable

Another option worth considering is TrueCar, which partners with certified dealers and provides price transparency on used Forester models, helping buyers understand if they're getting a competitive price.

What to Inspect When Buying a Used Forester Premium

When evaluating a used Subaru Forester Premium, several key inspection points can help ensure you're making a sound investment. Start with the vehicle history report from services like Carfax or AutoCheck to verify accident history, title status, and service records. Particularly with Foresters, check for consistent maintenance of the all-wheel drive system and CVT transmission.

The head gasket has been a historical concern in some older Subaru engines, so for models older than 2012, have a mechanic specifically check this component. For newer models (2017 and up), this is less of a concern due to design improvements. Additionally, inspect the panoramic sunroof operation, as repairs can be costly if malfunctioning.

Test all electronic features, particularly the infotainment system and EyeSight driver assistance features if equipped. These systems should function perfectly and any warning lights should be addressed before purchase. The X-Mode off-road assistance feature should also be tested if possible.

Pay close attention to the condition of the boxer engine by listening for unusual sounds and checking for oil leaks, which can indicate potential issues. Subaru engines are known for their longevity when properly maintained, but neglected maintenance can lead to expensive repairs. A pre-purchase inspection by a mechanic familiar with Subaru vehicles is always a wise investment before finalizing your purchase.

Price Expectations for Used Forester Premium Models

Used Subaru Forester Premium pricing varies significantly based on model year, mileage, condition, and your location. For perspective, recent-model used Forester Premiums (2019-2022) typically range from $25,000 to $32,000 depending on mileage and condition. These fifth-generation models command higher prices due to their updated technology and safety features.

Fourth-generation models (2014-2018) offer more affordable options, usually priced between $15,000 and $23,000 for Premium trim levels. Vehicles with lower mileage (under 50,000 miles) and comprehensive service records typically command prices at the higher end of these ranges.

Certified Pre-Owned (CPO) Forester Premiums from Subaru dealerships generally cost about $1,500-$2,500 more than non-certified equivalents but include extended warranty coverage and have undergone more rigorous inspection processes. This premium may be worth considering for the additional peace of mind.

When evaluating pricing, use tools from Kelley Blue Book or Edmunds to determine fair market value based on your specific region. Prices can fluctuate seasonally, with all-wheel drive vehicles like the Forester sometimes commanding higher prices in winter months or in regions with challenging weather conditions.

Remember that the Premium trim represents the sweet spot in the Forester lineup, offering many desirable features without the higher cost of Limited or Touring models. This makes them particularly popular in the used market and can help them maintain stronger resale value compared to base models.

Conclusion

A used Subaru Forester Premium offers an excellent balance of capability, features, and value for shoppers seeking a reliable all-wheel-drive SUV. By understanding what to look for in different model years, comparing marketplace options, conducting thorough inspections, and setting realistic price expectations, you can confidently find a pre-owned Forester Premium that meets your needs.

Remember that while the Premium trim provides significant upgrades over the base model, it typically costs less than higher trims while still offering the essential features most drivers value. With proper research and inspection, a used Forester Premium can provide many years of reliable service, making it a smart choice for practical SUV shoppers who value both capability and comfort.

Citations

This content was written by AI and reviewed by a human for quality and compliance.