Smart Ways To Get Metromile Insurance for Your Rental Car

Navigating rental car insurance options can be confusing and costly. Metromile offers pay-per-mile insurance that might extend to your rental vehicles, potentially saving you money at the counter. Before declining the rental agency's coverage, understanding how Metromile works with rentals is essential.

What Metromile Insurance Covers for Rental Cars

Metromile operates differently from traditional auto insurance companies. Their pay-per-mile model charges a base rate plus a per-mile fee, making it particularly attractive for low-mileage drivers. When it comes to rental cars, Metromile typically extends your personal auto policy coverage to your rental vehicle when driving within the United States.

The standard Metromile policy includes comprehensive and collision coverage that generally transfers to rental cars. This means if you already have full coverage on your personal vehicle through Metromile, you might not need to purchase the rental company's Collision Damage Waiver (CDW) or Loss Damage Waiver (LDW). However, coverage limits and deductibles from your personal policy will apply to the rental vehicle as well, which is an important consideration when evaluating your protection needs.

It's worth noting that Metromile's coverage for rentals typically lasts up to 30 days. For longer rental periods, you might need to contact Metromile directly to discuss your options or consider supplemental coverage from the rental agency or a third party.

How Metromile's Rental Car Coverage Works

When you rent a car while holding a Metromile policy, your liability coverage transfers automatically in most cases. This means your policy's bodily injury and property damage protection follows you to the rental vehicle. Additionally, if you have comprehensive and collision coverage on your personal vehicle, these protections typically extend to your rental.

One unique aspect of Metromile's coverage is how they handle the mileage charges. Unlike your personal vehicle that uses the Metromile Pulse device to track mileage, rental cars won't have this device installed. Metromile has policies in place to address this tracking gap, often not charging for rental car mileage if the rental is due to a covered claim. However, for personal rentals, you should clarify with Metromile how they'll account for those miles.

Before renting, it's advisable to contact Metromile's customer service to verify exactly what is covered under your specific policy. Some policy exclusions might apply depending on the type of vehicle rented or the purpose of the rental. For instance, rentals for business purposes might have different coverage rules than those for personal use.

Metromile vs. Other Rental Car Insurance Options

When comparing rental car coverage options, it's important to understand how Metromile stacks up against alternatives. Here's a comparison of common rental car insurance sources:

Insurance Source	Coverage Type	Typical Cost	Key Benefits
Metromile	Extension of personal policy	No additional cost (existing policy)	Pay-per-mile structure potentially saves money
Rental Agency (e.g., Enterprise)	Collision Damage Waiver	$10-$30 per day	Zero deductible, simplified claims
Credit Card (e.g., American Express)	Secondary collision coverage	Included with card	No daily fees, automatic when using card
Third-party (e.g., Allianz)	Stand-alone rental coverage	$7-$15 per day	Often more comprehensive than credit cards

While Hertz and other rental agencies push their coverage packages at the counter, using your Metromile policy could save you significant money. However, there are scenarios where rental agency coverage might be preferable, such as when you want to avoid potential claims on your personal policy or when you need higher limits than what your Metromile policy provides.

Credit card coverage from providers like Visa can be another cost-effective option, though it's typically secondary coverage that only kicks in after your personal auto insurance. This means you would still need to file a claim with Metromile first, potentially affecting your rates.

Benefits and Limitations of Using Metromile for Rentals

Benefits of using Metromile for rental cars include:

Cost savings by avoiding daily rental agency insurance fees
Consistent coverage between your personal and rental vehicles
Simplified process with fewer decisions at the rental counter
Potential savings through Metromile's pay-per-mile structure

Limitations to consider:

Your Metromile deductible applies (often higher than rental agency options)
Claims affect your personal insurance history and potentially future rates
Coverage gaps may exist for certain vehicle types or uses
International rentals typically not covered

One significant advantage of Metromile's coverage is that it typically includes liability protection, which many credit card policies and some third-party options don't offer. This comprehensive approach means you have both damage and liability protection under one policy.

However, if you rent luxury vehicles, trucks, or specialty vehicles, Metromile might have coverage restrictions or exclusions. Additionally, if you're traveling internationally, your Metromile policy generally won't extend to rentals outside the United States, making rental agency coverage or travel insurance more appropriate for foreign trips.

Maximizing Value with Metromile Rental Coverage

To get the most from your Metromile policy when renting vehicles, follow these strategic approaches:

Request a coverage letter from Metromile before renting to show at the counter
Review your policy details to understand coverage limits and exclusions
Consider supplemental liability insurance if your Metromile limits are low
Check if your rental period falls within Metromile's coverage timeframe

When declining rental agency coverage, rental agents may pressure you to reconsider. Having documentation from Metromile confirming your coverage can help you confidently decline unnecessary add-ons. Some rental locations may place a larger hold on your credit card if you decline their coverage, so be prepared for this possibility.

For frequent renters, consider how rental car usage might impact your overall Metromile premium. If you're primarily a low-mileage driver but occasionally rent cars for longer trips, the pay-per-mile structure might still work in your favor overall compared to traditional insurance. However, clarify with Metromile how rental miles factor into your billing to avoid surprises.

Finally, remember that Avis, Budget, and other rental companies often offer package deals with insurance included. Compare these all-in prices against the combination of their base rate plus your existing Metromile coverage to determine the truly better value.

Conclusion

Metromile's pay-per-mile insurance can offer substantial savings for rental cars, particularly for occasional drivers. By understanding exactly what your policy covers, you can make informed decisions at the rental counter and potentially avoid unnecessary insurance costs. Before your next trip, contact Metromile directly to confirm your rental coverage details and request documentation. While their coverage works well for many domestic rentals, remember that international trips, specialty vehicles, or business uses may require additional protection. Balancing the convenience of rental agency coverage against the cost savings of using your existing Metromile policy ultimately depends on your specific circumstances, risk tolerance, and travel needs.

Citations

This content was written by AI and reviewed by a human for quality and compliance.