What Is an Online Criminal Background Check?

An online criminal background check is a screening process that searches public records to reveal a person's criminal history. These checks typically include searches of county, state, and federal court records, as well as sex offender registries and terrorist watchlists. They're designed to help employers make informed hiring decisions while maintaining compliance with relevant laws.

The depth and scope of these checks can vary significantly based on the employer's needs and the position being filled. For example, positions involving financial responsibility or work with vulnerable populations often require more comprehensive screening. Most background checks reveal information about felony and misdemeanor convictions, pending criminal cases, and sometimes arrest records, depending on state regulations.

How Online Criminal Background Checks Work

The process typically begins when an employer partners with a background check provider. After obtaining the candidate's consent (which is legally required), the employer submits the applicant's personal information such as full name, date of birth, and Social Security number to the screening company.

The background check provider then searches various databases and public records to compile the report. This process can take anywhere from a few hours to several days, depending on the jurisdictions being searched and the complexity of the check. Some counties still require manual courthouse searches, which can extend the timeline.

Once complete, employers receive a report detailing any criminal history found. It's important to note that employers must follow adverse action procedures outlined in the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) if they decide not to hire someone based on information in their background check.

Provider Comparison for Background Check Services

Several reputable companies offer online criminal background check services, each with different strengths and specializations:

  • GoodHire - Known for user-friendly interfaces and excellent customer support. GoodHire offers customizable packages suitable for businesses of all sizes.
  • Sterling - Specializes in enterprise-level solutions with advanced AI technology. Sterling provides global screening capabilities for multinational corporations.
  • HireRight - Offers extensive international coverage and integration with many applicant tracking systems. HireRight is particularly popular among large employers.
  • Checkr - Utilizes advanced technology for faster results and better candidate experience. Checkr is favored by many technology companies and gig economy platforms.
  • Accurate Background - Provides comprehensive compliance support and educational resources. Accurate Background offers solutions tailored to specific industries.

When selecting a provider, consider factors like turnaround time, compliance support, customer service quality, and integration capabilities with your existing HR systems.

Benefits and Limitations of Employment Background Checks

Online criminal background checks offer several advantages to employers. They help reduce hiring risks by identifying candidates with relevant criminal histories that might affect job performance or workplace safety. These checks can also help protect against negligent hiring claims and ensure regulatory compliance in industries with specific requirements.

However, these checks also have limitations. Background check databases aren't always complete or up-to-date. Some jurisdictions don't digitize all their records, and information can sometimes be reported inaccurately. Additionally, over-reliance on background checks might eliminate qualified candidates who have rehabilitated themselves after past mistakes.

Employers must also navigate complex legal requirements. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission advises against blanket policies that exclude all applicants with criminal records, as this may have a disparate impact on certain protected groups. Instead, employers should consider the nature of the crime, its relevance to the position, and how much time has passed since the conviction.

Pricing and Implementation Considerations

The cost of online criminal background checks varies widely based on the depth of the search and the provider selected. Basic checks might start around $20-30 per candidate, while comprehensive screenings can cost $100 or more. Many providers offer volume-based pricing for businesses that conduct numerous checks.

When implementing a background check program, companies should consider several factors beyond just cost. These include integration with existing HR systems, compliance support, customer service quality, and reporting capabilities. TalentWise and BackgroundChecks.com both offer consultative services to help companies develop appropriate screening policies.

It's also crucial to establish clear procedures for handling adverse information. This includes determining which types of offenses are relevant to specific positions and creating consistent evaluation criteria. Many employers work with legal counsel to develop these guidelines and ensure compliance with ban-the-box laws and other regulations that vary by location.

Conclusion

Online criminal background checks serve as an important tool in the modern hiring process, helping employers make informed decisions while maintaining safe workplaces. When implemented thoughtfully and in compliance with relevant laws, these screenings can benefit both employers and candidates. The key is finding the right balance between thorough vetting and providing opportunities for qualified candidates regardless of past mistakes. As technology and regulations continue to evolve, employers should regularly review their background check policies to ensure they remain effective, fair, and legally compliant. Remember that background checks are just one component of a comprehensive hiring strategy that should also include interviews, skills assessments, and reference checks.

Citations

This content was written by AI and reviewed by a human for quality and compliance.